Bob Shaffer of the Foundation Architects was interviewed by Christian White of White & Associates Practice Consulting. The podcast topics included:
The future of optometry clinic design changes slowly. Now, with a global pandemic and its associated new industry guidelines, quick changes are necessary. Some of these changes will be in management and operations, and other changes will be to your testing tools and equipment; however this discussion will focus on certain architectural design implications of this pandemic, the physical environment, and the future design of optometry clinics.
Optometry Clinic Design must change… now. Architectural design focuses on the physical environment, specifically the enclosed physical environment. It’s important to note that the architectural design of a clinic significantly affects how it works, as the design significantly affects its processes. The layout of your spaces, configuration of your physical equipment and the ventilation systems in your clinic have a major impact on health and safety, now, and into the future.
By separating testing spaces, we can decrease the movement of contaminants from person to person. Many clinics already have full divider walls within Pretest Rooms, but for those with testing equipment open to other equipment, dividers will be needed. These dividers may include new partitions, glazing with glass or plastics, or a temporary divider with inexpensive acrylic panels hung from the ceiling or supported on a partial wall. Whether a management effort or a marketing effort for your clinic, your staff has always cleaned the exam rooms between patients; now, more than ever, you should visually alert your patients to your cleaning practices by putting small reusable and cleanable signage out that says “Sterilized Chair” or “Sanitized Exam Room.” As your patient enters the room they will clearly see your staff move the sign off the chair, reassuring them of the cleanliness of your office.
Improve your clinic’s air quality. Airflow significantly effects comfort and the movement of viral aerosols in an optometry clinic. There are many ways to control airflow in a typical exam room with the typical solution to blow heated or cooled air into the space over the window or exterior wall of the clinic and pulling the return air through the ceiling in the hallway outside of the exam room. This creates a flow of air, which is considered “positive” pressure within the exam room, like the air movement from a blowing fan, pushing the flow of air into the hallway, which is pulling the air out and considered “negative” pressure, like the suction of a vacuum. With current concerns about air born viruses and contaminants in the clinics, this common and widespread design solution may be short-lived. A better approach will be to keep the exam rooms under negative pressure, pulling the air into the rooms, and exhausting the return air directly outside or through a high level of filtration, like a HEPA filter, prior to recirculating that air. You can even enhance this filtration with systems such as ultraviolet (UV) light or ozone which can kill viruses and bacteria. While negative pressure within the exam rooms is beneficial for containing the aerosols, it has its downsides; it may draw contaminated air from the hallway, possibly creating uncomfortable drafts on the patient, and it simply costs more. Retrofitting a clinic in this way may typically be infeasible; however, if planning a new clinic, this would be a potential design direction. Most existing systems can be updated with HEPA filters and UV or ozone systems, utilizing your current ductwork for modest costs.
Protection of your staff as well as patients from contamination is critically important, since they will have multiple interactions throughout a day. State Optometric Associations are recommending barriers between patient treatments or testing, however, you may also want to consider providing temporary clear barriers at your reception and fitting desks protecting your reception staff and patients. These barriers would be similar to those being used for retail grocery clerk areas with multiple panels of clear acrylic or glass temporarily set or mounted to the front reception desk to shield the receptionists and related staff, like common cafeteria line sneeze guards. In the future, clinics may incorporate some form of separation at the reception desk, with more permanent glass or resin panels, while maintaining a satisfactory level of personal connection to the patients.
Toilet Rooms may need physical considerations beyond simply sanitization. Hands-free faucets, soap dispensers, and paper towel dispensers/hand dryers should now be the standard for every public toilet in your clinic. You can easily retrofit hands-free faucets at every sink in your clinic, including the often overlooked breakroom sink.
Retail and waiting room changes are being recommended by industry guidelines as a pandemic response, with most of these being procedural or management of patients and their families or attendants, including staggering of entrance timing and limiting occupants. These are temporary measures meant to minimize cross-interactions of your patients. Some of the changes you may make will be temporary, while you may find others may actually increase your productivity and efficiency, so should be kept in place. The less touching of devices, paperwork, and shoulder-to-shoulder seating in a waiting room the better to reduce transmission of viruses and other illnesses. It is time to rethink the waiting room. Here are some ideas:
When it comes to controlling contaminants in your clinic environment, many possible solutions are available for new clinic designs and for pandemic-related retrofits, but they will vary from clinic to clinic and location to location. As the pandemic situation is rapidly changing, keep a creative eye on all evolving solutions and recommendations. Some of these changes may become long-term best practices in your clinic, so plan for the future of what your clinic should be. Tap into resources from optometric association guidelines and connect with your optometry architect for their professional advice, specific design ideas, and problem solving. Most important of all, be considerate of others by keeping your team and your patients safe.
We’re here to help! If you have questions about the future of optometry clinic design or want to discuss a project, contact Bob at bob@foundationarch.com or 612-340-5430
The future of dental clinic design fluctuates like a butterfly in the wind. Now, with a global pandemic and its associated new industry guidelines, changes are necessary in dental clinic design. Some of these changes will be in management and operations, and other changes will be to your dental tools and equipment; however this discussion will focus on certain architectural design implications of this pandemic, the physical environment, and the future design of dental clinics.
Dental Clinic Design must change… now. Architectural design focuses on the physical environment, specifically the enclosed physical environment. It’s important to note that the architectural design of a dental clinic significantly affects how a dental clinic works, as it significantly affects its processes. The layout of your spaces, configuration of your physical equipment and the ventilation systems in your clinic have a major impact on health and safety now and into the future.
One significant challenge for dental clinics during the COVID-19 pandemic is how to control the movement of aerosols within a clinic. Aerosols are suspended particles or droplets created by high speed dental equipment such as scalers, burs & air/water tips that potentially contain viruses, bacteria, and even blood. These aerosols are small enough to float in the air and can travel wherever the air flow takes them, possibly spreading up to 30 feet. The movement of aerosols within a clinic can be controlled in many different ways; solutions can be permanent, temporary, costly or cost-effective; there is not a magic formula for what works best, as each dental clinic and each business will need to weigh the benefits and drawbacks and decide on the best solution for your staff, patients, and business. In our pandemic environment, it is critical to reduce the flow of aerosols between treatment rooms while also reducing the flow into the hallway and circulation areas.
By separating treatment spaces, we can decrease the movement of aerosols from room to room. Many clinics already have full divider walls between treatment rooms, but for those that are using partial height cabinetry or partial height walls between treatment rooms there are solutions to close off those areas to reduce transmission of aerosols such as with new partitions, glazing with glass or plastics, or a temporary divider with inexpensive acrylic panels hung from the ceiling or supported on the partial wall or cabinets. Other options to minimize transmission of aerosols include screening devices, non-porous screening, or soffits to close off the openings. Whether a management effort or a marketing effort for your clinic, your staff has always cleaned the treatment rooms between patients; now, more than ever, you should visually alert your patients to your cleaning practices by putting small reusable and cleanable signage out that says “Sterilized Chair” or “Sanitized Exam Room.” As your patient enters the room they will clearly see your staff move the sign off the chair, reassuring them of the cleanliness of your office.
Improve your clinic’s air quality. Airflow significantly effects comfort and the movement of aerosols in a dental clinic. There are many ways to control airflow in a typical treatment room with the typical solution to blow heated or cooled air into the space over the window or exterior wall of the clinic and pulling the return air through the ceiling in the hallway outside of the treatment room. This creates a flow of air, that is considered “positive” pressure within the treatment room, like the air movement from a blowing fan, pushing the flow of air into the hallway, which is pulling the air out and considered “negative” pressure, like the suction of a vacuum. With current concerns about aerosols in the treatment rooms, this common and widespread design solution may be short-lived. A better approach would be to keep the treatment rooms under negative pressure, pulling the air into the rooms, and exhausting the return air directly outside or through a high level of filtration, like a HEPA filter, prior to recirculating that air. You can even enhance this filtration with systems such as ultraviolet (UV) light or ozone which can kill viruses and bacteria. While negative pressure within the treatment rooms is beneficial for containing the aerosols, it has its downsides; it may draw contaminated air from the hallway, possibly creating uncomfortable drafts on the patient, and it simply costs more. Retrofitting a clinic in this way may typically be infeasible; however, if planning a new clinic, this would be a potential design direction. Most existing systems can be updated with HEPA filters and UV or ozone systems, utilizing your current ductwork for modest costs.
Protection of your staff as well as patients from contamination is critically important, since they will have multiple interactions throughout a day. The ADA and state Dental Associations are recommending barriers between treatment areas, however, you may also want to consider providing temporary clear barriers at your reception desk protecting your reception staff and patients. These barriers would be similar to those being used for retail grocery clerk areas with multiple panels of clear acrylic or glass temporarily set or mounted to the front reception desk to shield the receptionists and related staff, like common cafeteria line sneeze guards. In the future, clinics may incorporate some form of separation at the reception desk, with more permanent glass or resin panels, while maintaining a satisfactory level of personal connection to the patients.
Toilet rooms may need physical considerations beyond simply sanitization. Hands-free faucets, soap dispensers, and paper towel dispensers/hand dryers should now be the standard for every public toilet in your clinic. You can easily retrofit hands-free faucets at every sink in your clinic, including the often overlooked breakroom sink.
Waiting room changes are being recommended by industry guidelines as a pandemic response, with most of these being procedural or management of patients and their families or attendants, including staggering of entrance timing. These are temporary measures meant to minimize cross-interactions of your patients. Some of the changes you may make will be temporary, while you may find others may actually increase your productivity and efficiency, so should be kept in place. The less touching of devices, paperwork, and shoulder-to-shoulder seating in a waiting room the better to reduce transmission of viruses and other illnesses. It is time to rethink the waiting room. Here are some ideas:
When it comes to controlling contaminants in your clinic environment, many possible solutions are available for new clinic designs and for pandemic-related retrofits, but they will vary from clinic to clinic and location to location. As the pandemic situation is rapidly changing, keep a creative eye on all evolving solutions and recommendations. Some of these changes may become long-term best practices in your clinic, so plan for the future of what your clinic should be. Tap into resources from dental industry guidelines and connect with your dental architect for their professional advice, specific design ideas, and problem solving. Most important of all, be considerate of others by keeping your team and your patients safe.
We’re here to help! If you have questions about the future of dental clinic design or want to discuss a project, contact Bob at bob@foundationarch.com or 612-340-5430
Wink Family Eye Care featured in an article about how to fit an optometry clinic into a small footprint and have it appear spacious.
Both Wink Family Eye Care Clinics earned Honorable Mention awards from Invision Magazine in 2019.
